Czytaj recenzję

• http://www.largescaleplanes.com • 2016-06-09
• SAM 06/2015 • 2015-05-28
• Airfix Model World 53 • 2015-04-01
• Cybermodeler.com • 2015-04-01

• http://www.largescaleplanes.com • 2016-06-09

  Reviewed by Iain Ogilvie

  

  Some time ago I reviewed Radu's previous tome on the IAR fighters published by SAM publications 'The I.A.R.80 & I.A.R.81 - Airframe, Systems & Equipment' thinking that would be the ultimate printed reference on these attractive and interesting aeroplanes. This 'new' book, again by Radu Brinzan, knocks the previous monograph into the weeds and is the definitive work on these aeroplanes to date. In fact - I doubt it could be bettered.

  

  Publisher's Overview

  A detailed and comprehensive illustrated technical history of the I.A.R.80 and I.A.R.81 - the Romanian World War II fighter and ground-attack aircraft. This elegant but little-known aircraft was the mainstay of the Romanian air force's fighter arm throughout World War II, involved in fighting against both the Allies and then against the Axis.

  It was heavily involved in aerial battles against USAAF heavy bombers attacking Romanian oil fields. The different versions of the plane are described and illustrated; all the changes in specification, equipment and performance are recorded. Drawings and data from the original technical manuals, full dimensional details and photographs of the few surviving relics preserved in aviation museums illustrate all aspects of the airframe, inside and out. 60 colour photographs and many pages of colour illustrations complete the book's comprehensive coverage. Includes accurate 1/48th scale plans, and colour profiles showing many of the colourful schemes applied to the aircraft.

  Hardback, 368 pages, over 1000 photos and illustrations, scale 1/48 drawings for all versions.

  Content

  The book opens with an introduction - under the very appropriate heading of "The Most Famous Fighter You Never Heard Of", followed by a comprehensive list of acknowledgements and a brief history of Industria Aeronautică Română (I.A.R. Braşov), before diving into technical content with Chapter Two - "Evolution of I.A.R. 80 and 81. In this chapter Radu takes the reader through every batch of airframes by number with high quality line drawings specific to that batch, along with photographs, specifications and relevant text. From this information alone the reader gains a detailed understanding of the differences between each airframe that I've never seen before in any other aviation monograph - it really is very detailed and will enable the modeller to get their model right with regard to individual variations.

  Chapter Three deals with Maintenance Instructions, Flying the I.A.R. 80, Flight Characteristics, complaints About the I.A.R. 80, Planned Versions, and even costs! As a private pilot, as well as a modeller, I found the notes on Flying and Flight Characteristics particularly interesting, but all of the content will inspire and provide a wonderful background and feel for the subject. Chapter Three closes with detailed specification tables, manufacturing timeline and contract details, as well as a useful 'evolution' diagram showing the development tree.

  Getting Technical

  The next chapters bring us to the kind of structural and systems details that we modellers absolutely love and contains more details, drawings and photographs than you could have thought possible for a relatively esoteric series of aeroplanes. I think it's probably best described as modellers porn and could provide enough material to enable you to create that perfect stripped down and detailed airframe in model form. These chapters are broken down as follows:

  • Chapter Four - Forward and Rear Fuselage
  • Chapter Five - Cockpit with detailed technical drawings and photographs, Gunsights, Instruments and Instrument panels, Headrests, Canopy and Windscreen.
  • Chapter Six - Wings - line drawings, manufacturers drawings photos and text for all variations
  • Chapter Seven - Control Surfaces - covering Ailerons, flaps, Tailplane, Elevators, Tail Fin and Rudder, Empennage Mounting and flight Controls
  • Chapter Eight - Systems - including Engine, Engine Mount, Propeller, exhausts, Cowl, Cooling Flaps, Engine Controls, Air Filters and Ducts, Heated Intake, Engine Start and Engine Heater
  • Chapter Nine - Landing Gear - Wheels and Brakes, Gear Doors,Retraction and Extension System, Wheel Wells and Tail Skid
  • Chapter Ten - Systems - including Fuel System, Drop Tank, Oil System, Hydraulic System, Pnuematic System, Electrical System and Radio
  • Chapter Eleven - Weapons
  • Chapter Twelve - Safety Systems - harnesses etc.

  Colours and Camouflage

  If it's the technical details that can make a model, it's the finish that can break it. Here we have superbly researched information on the colours and markings used on these aeroplanes. Material starts with a written background on the colours used - backed up with component photographs showing the original colours used. This is followed by a beautiful selection of period colour images, background and colour illustrations on Camouflage Schemes, National Insignia (covering all variations), Theatre Markings and Stencils.

  Accessories

  Chapter Fourteen rounds out some of the technical content with information, photos and drawings detailing Service and Maintenance Tools, Covers and even the aircrew Flight Gear.

  Annexes cover Survivors and Replicas, Romanian Pronunciation (!), Romanian Aviation Unit Structure, Aviation Ranks, Timeline of Events, Glossary and Bibliography.

  Colour Profiles

  The final part of the book provides 16 pages of top quality colour profiles, covering all variations - 59 plates in all. The ONLY downside - if you're anything like me you'll come away inspired to build quite a few more than just the one model!

  It would be unfair to the author to show too much of the content here, but the following images should give a taste:

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  ---

  Conclusion

  When I reviewed Radu's previous work on the subject I made the rash statement that I doubted it would ever be bettered. Well, it has - and in very fine style. This book provides a huge amount of additional material, along with a few corrections from additional research and information that came to light after Radu's first book on the subject.

  If you've got the FRROM kit I can highly recommended this book - every bit of information you could need to build a museum quality model - and learn some fascinating history in the process!

  Available directly from RB Productions at €69.75. Not cheap - but for a book of this quality, with such in-depth research an a subject that's hard to find information on, I firmly believe it represents good value. Oh - and it's a similar price to the kit - and a very worthy companion!

  If you have even the slightest interest in these aeroplanes, or are looking for the perfect kit/reference combination for your next project, go buy this book before they're all gone. Superb!

  Iain

  © Iain Ogilvie 2016

• SAM 06/2015 • 2015-05-28
  
• Airfix Model World 53 • 2015-04-01
  
• Cybermodeler.com • 2015-04-01

  By David L. Veres

  Review

  What you say about a book that devotes three pages to headrests alone? Three more to a safety harness? And another five to gunsights?

  You'd call it Vanator - Romanian Hunter – MMP's latest, available in North America from Casemate. Spanning nearly 400 pages and reflecting two decades of "intense study and research", it's significantly subtitled, "The I.A.R.80 and I.A.R.81 in Ultimate Detail".

  And that, as Cary Grant quipped to Katherine Hepburn, is a "masterpiece of understatement". This massive, magnificent monograph proffers metaphorical mountains of minutiae.

  How often should you grease I.A.R.80 aileron and flap hinges? It's here. The structure and disposition of wings and armament? Yep. Specifications for Romania's World War II-vintage "King Michael Cross"? Definitely. Hatch and panel locations for every version? Those, too. All instrument permutations – in full color? Absolutely.

  Even a guide to Romanian phonetics. Now I can accurately pronounce the book's title!

  An enlarged and corrected version of an earlier edition from SAM Publications, Vanator - Romanian Hunter sports hundreds of B&W photographs, 1:48-scale line drawings, isometrics and original tech-manual excerpts. Dozens of color plates – profiles, insets, insignia and serials, all with reference photos – also spice MMP's superb study.

  You name it, it's here. Radu Brinzan's colossal compendium has easily established a quality benchmark for future aircraft monographs. And it carries my highest recommendation.

  Now let's hope some enterprising model manufacturer references MMP's terrific tome for a new, accurate and lavishly detailed family of I.A.R.80 kits!

  With thanks to MMP for the review copy.